Coneball
Flour Tag
Frisbee Golf
Glow in the dark dodge ball
Glow in the dark volleyball
Have a bowling night.  Let everyone bring a younger sibling or ward member.
Human Foosball
I bought a Chinese Jump Rope for about $2 and taught my girls how to play. We used to play all the time when I was in school, but these girls had never even heard of it! They LOVED it, and have asked my several times since then if we can play again. I also brought jacks, another game I played when I was small, but has since gone "out of fashion." They loved it also! (Idea by Michelle)
Missionary Tag - It's a game like tag, but in pairs. Every girl pairs up and hooks one arm.  All the girls stand in a circle or box but spread out. Two girls start in the middle, one being "it". The other girl runs to one of the pair of girls hooking her arm in one of the girls that is paired up. When she hooks her arm to the one girl the other girl in the pair then runs to hook her arm to another girl. She is trying to do this before the girl that is "it" tags her. If she gets tagged she is it and the other girls runs to hook arms. When the girls get tired of running, they sometimes change the rules where they might skip, hop, or walk. They've even played where the two girls paired up are turning around in a circle. (Idea by Daphne Brimhall)
  Play baseball with a tennis racquet and tennis ball.
Scripture Dodgeball - You divide into teams and play dodgeball.  As they get out they have to answer a question about the gospel, whether its church, scripture, past prophets, anything. When they get one right they can go back in.
Siamese Baseball
Water Baseball
Wheelbarrow Baseball